Confession: I used to watch soap operas. My poison of choice was General Hospital. I would rush back to my dorm after class, where my roommate and I would tune in at 3:00pm to ooh and aah over the latest love quarrel, blackmail plot, or alcoholic rage… Will Carly choose Sonny or Jason? And will she be satisfied with a marriage to a known (and sometimes-convicted) mobster? Why does Laura still love Luke despite the romantic advances of the mysterious Stefan Cassadine and Luke’s less-than-respectable scheming to place Laura in a mental institution? Would Alan Quartermaine overcome his alcoholism and save his marriage to grief-ridden Monica? Would Maxie Jones get the heart transplant in time?
Oh! The drama!
Day after day I tuned in. I would agonize over missing an episode and would… sadly… rearrange my schedule so I could be home in time.
Well, the good news is this: I grew up. I graduated. I got a job… one that would require office hours well-past my beloved 3:00pm time slot. And aside from a sick day here and there or a vacation day or two, I haven’t tuned in to General Hospital since.
Maybe it’s because I know I could pick it up again and see the same storylines repeated that I’d feel like I hadn’t missed anything.
Or maybe it’s because I knew I’d get my drama-fix elsewhere…
***
I just finished month 2 of The Dare—having previously read The Scarlet Letter, I spent the last four weeks reading all 34 sultry, electrifying, suspenseful, and… yes… dramatic chapters of Wuthering Heights.
Do you want to know what I said after turning that last page?
I miss General Hospital.
Though the pages placed me in the soggy moors of historic England, I feel like I just spent 28 days back in the small-hospital town of Port Charles, NY, where Carly’s whining had Sonny (the mobster) and Jason (the backup boyfriend) running around like fools trying to prove their love and appease the fantasies of the girly main character.
But instead of Carly, I was reading about Catherine, ten times more selfish than her Port Charles counterpart.
Instead of Sonny, I was reading about Heathcliff, likewise mobster through and through.
And instead of Jason, I was reading about Edgar Linton, the emasculated second choice who despite being a genuine person, always appeared weaker than his competition.
Much to the chagrin of classic literature enthusiasts, I think the writers of General Hospital were better at the love triangle than Ms. Emily Bronte. Sorry, Emily.
WHAT?!?! Ooomigoodness. You didn’t just say that. I KNOW you didn’t.
Oh, but I did, dear readers. I did.
And I won’t apologize for it.
I had hoped to adore Catherine, but she was just a little too self-absorbed. I wanted to admire Edgar, but he was just too wimpy. And I really wanted to fall in love with Heathcliff, but he was just too… too… too… what?
Miserable? Yep.
No good? Sure.
Selfish? Absolutely.
Egomaniacal, begrudging, attention-loving beast? Yeah, that about covers it.
An enchanting name will only take you so far, Heathcliff, and though I still dream of using your alluring and completely romantic moniker for my firstborn son (barring any serious objection from my future husband, of course), the fact of the matter is… I don’t like you.
Now don’t get me wrong, readers. The book wasn’t all bad. The language was fantastic and I am still marveling over the writing (See Quotables: Wuthering Heights). But I had a hard time respecting the aforementioned characters, the plot was too dramatic and suffered under the weight of the selfish rants of these characters, and said-rants made the entire story completely unbelievable.
And therein is the problem. Though I fully admit to dreaming about the happily-ever-after, I do so because at least part of me believes that it can be true; that there IS such a thing.
Isn’t that true, though, of ALL fiction enthusiasts? Somehow, some part of them wants to believe that what they are reading could come true. They want to escape from their life (which likely pales in comparison to the lives they live inside the pages of books) and experience something other than what they know. Because they adore that life, long for that life, and—for at least a couple hundred pages—can experience that life.
When a novel becomes unbelievable, it falls out of that realm of experience. And, at least in the Cat’s eyes, falls out of the reader’s minds.
I’m sure I’m a better-read person for having finished Wuthering Heights, but it’s not a book I will recommend, nor is it one that I think I’ll remember and pick up again ten years from now. So with this less-than-stellar report, I happily move on to the March selection: Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey.
Here’s hoping for a better experience this month.





